Our handmade chocolate covered Jellies are available in 3 delightful flavors and contains a dollop of fruit jelly. Flavors include: Raspberry Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), Orange Jellies (available in milk & dark chocolate), and Peanut Butter & Grape Jellies (available in milk chocolate only).
Chocolate Miniatures
Regular price
$6.25
Save $-6.25
/
Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk chocolate. Available in a 4oz. bag. (not season specific)
Fall Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers
Regular price
$1.50
Save $-1.50
/
Take a break from the hooting and hollering of the holidays with this crisp chocolate-covered Graham cracker with fall decor. Sold individually.
Fall Chocolate Covered Oreos
Regular price
$3.50
Save $-3.50
/
A pair of crisp Oreo sandwich cookies enrobed in creamy milk chocolate, topped off with fall decor.
Fluffer Nutter Candy
Regular price
$3.00
Save $-3.00
/
This is our "new" must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow. Sold per piece.
Foiled Chocolate Leaves
Regular price
$6.50
Save $-6.50
/
Not everyone knows the meaning of "deciduous," but everyone knows the meaning of "delicious." These individually foil-wrapped, solid milk chocolate leaves are ready to fall into your candy dish. *Available in dark chocolate too!!
Gummy Worms
Regular price
$3.25
Save $-3.25
/
Our fruit-flavored Gummy Worms are soft and sweet. Enjoy a 12 oz. bag of our Gummy Worms.
Milk Chocolate Letters
Regular price
$3.00
Save $-3.00
/
Mix & Match your favorite letters to create a customizable gift that also serves as a sweet treat!
Milk Chocolate Non-Pareils
Regular price
$6.00
Save $-6.00
/
Colorful candy sprinkles combine with milk chocolate for a texture as crisp as a late autumn day.
Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.
Milk Chocolate Pilgrim Lollipop
Regular price
$1.60
Save $-1.60
/
Not only is this solid milk chocolate Pilgrim man portable, he's Mayflower Compact.
Milk Chocolate Scarecrow Lollipop
Regular price
$1.10
Save $-1.10
/
We'll eat crow if this solid milk chocolate scarecrow ruffles your feathers!
Milk Chocolate Turkey Lollipop
Regular price
$1.80
Save $-1.80
/
Stefanelli's milk chocolate is the best possible way to give yourself the bird.
Open Rose Sucker
Regular price
$2.55
Save $-2.55
/
Milk Chocolate open rose sucker 1.6oz
Peanut Butter Cups
Regular price
$12.00
Save $-12.00
/
Our homemade cups with peanut butter smoothie filling, available in milk, dark, or white chocolate.
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Regular price
$69.35
Sale price
$56.00
Save $13.35
/
2-large bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (15oz)
2-medium bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (5oz)
1-medium bag of dark chocolate sponge candy (5oz)
6-small bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (1.25oz)
Sugar Coated Gummy Pumpkins
Regular price
$3.25
Save $-3.25
/
Stefanelli's sugar-coated gummy pumpkins are the perfect fall treat. These pumpkin-shaped candies are a "gourd"-send for your fall candy dish. Available in a 12oz bag.
Tulip sucker
Regular price
$2.00
Save $-2.00
/
Milk Chocolate Tulip sucker 1.28oz
Calling all Sponge Candy Connoisseurs!
Check out the instant savings when you purchase a Sponge Candy Connoisseurs BUNDLE BOX (online only)