Everyday Sweets

Embrace both quantity and quality with Stefanelli Candies’ affordable everyday sweets, available by the pound in white, milk, and dark. No frills, just superior melt-in-your-mouth flavor. Great for use in your own baking or candy creations. 
7 products

7 products

Quick view
Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs
from $12.00
Quick view
Peanut Butter Cups
from $12.00
Quick view
Fluffer Nutter Candy
$3.00
Quick view
Milk Chocolate Letters
$3.00
Quick view
Tulip sucker
$2.00
Quick view
Open Rose Sucker
$2.55
Sale
Quick view
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
$69.35 $56.00 Save $13.35
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs
stefanelli's milk chocolate pecan frogs
stefanelli's pecan frogs

Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs

$12.00 Save $-12.00
/

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle — a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

stefanelli's milk chocolate peanut butter cups

Peanut Butter Cups

$12.00 Save $-12.00
/

Our homemade cups with peanut butter smoothie filling, available in milk,  dark, or white chocolate. 

stefanelli's fluffer nutter candy

Fluffer Nutter Candy

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/

This is our "new" must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow.
Sold per piece.

Milk Chocolate Letters

$3.00 Save $-3.00
/
Mix & Match your favorite letters to create a customizable gift that also serves as a sweet treat!
Tulip sucker

Tulip sucker

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/

Milk Chocolate Tulip sucker 1.28oz 

Open Rose Sucker

Open Rose Sucker

$2.55 Save $-2.55
/

Milk Chocolate open rose sucker 1.6oz

Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box
Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box

Sponge Candy Connoisseur Bundle Box

$69.35 $56.00 Save $13.35
/

2-large bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (15oz)

2-medium bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (5oz)

1-medium bag of dark chocolate sponge candy (5oz) 

6-small bags of milk chocolate sponge candy (1.25oz)